I guess then it might be a matter of seeing it in person because often that can provide a level of perspective that can't always be had online. As long as you're happy with what you got then that's all that matters. By the way, would you mind sharing what make and model of tire is on your Atlas? I ask that because from time to time they don't always offer the same spec of tire.The wheels are R-line wheels. They are gloss black like the front and back trim. When you go and pick up your vehical and everyone in the dealership is talking about that specific one and how it is the slicks one they have seen. You can tell you made the right choice. The dealer was impressed. Opinions are like assholes, everyone has one.