Volkswagen Atlas Forum banner

1 - 15 of 15 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Got my 2018 Atlas SEL Premium in March 2018. It has roughly 46,000 miles on it.

Short story: Why would the passenger side brake pads wear way faster (front passenger pad with 1/32 remaining, rear passenger pad 3/32 remaining) versus the driver side brake pads wearing appropriately with my mileage (front driver pad with 8/32 remaining, rear driver pad 6/32 remaining)

Long story: Took it in this week for a “grinding” noise that I was hearing from the front passenger brake pad and rotor. Originally I thought that something was stuck in between the pad and the rotor because back in September of 2018 there was an acorn of all things stuck in between the pad/rotor. The dealer called me within an hour or so and explained that they were surprised with the uneven wear from and that the pads should not have worn so much. They said they were going to do some test with the ABS system and check a few other things. They sent information to Volkswagen technical (whatever or whoever that is) and they said it was “normal” and to replace the pad/rotor. The dealer then asked for “assistance” from VW and they decline helping at all financially. Background... I had an unexplained vibration in the front passenger side that I had taken to another VW dealer two times. Each time they said they diagnosed the issue and just did an alignment each time to “fix” the problem.

So I called VW customer care and talked to a very nice lady that basically didn’t help at all. She apologized a bunch and basically told me she could not give me an explanation of WHY this is happening and to talk to the service manager. But I am not going to replace the pads/rotors without someone explaining WHY this is happening so that it doesn’t happen AGAIN!

HOW can this happen? Has anyone experienced this?
Who can I talk to at VW technical or something to get an answer?
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
882 Posts
Be realistic with the expectations. At 46K miles you will get zero warranty coverage for brakes. The dealer has done exactly what is to be expected and VW has said "normal". Have them replaced and move on. 46K on a set of pads/rotors isn't crazy for a large/heavy vehicle if the use was more around town than highway. Just my $0.02 of course. If it makes you feel better, my rotors are uneven at 21K and will get replaced in a few weeks. Just cost of owning any vehicle. Good luck!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
I totally agree with you on the warranty aspect... But someone needs to explain to me WHY they passenger side is basically gone and the drivers side is not!!!

There is an underlying issue here. I don't want to put a bandaid on this and then have to replace the passenger side twice as often as the driver's side.
 

·
Moderator
Joined
·
264 Posts
Welcome to the forum cqq99 ;)

If I had to guess, I would look into the Brake Hydraulic System :unsure:

Again, Welcome & Good Luck !
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4 Posts
Discussion Starter #6
That is the crazy part... The dealer techs looked at all of it and were shocked. Did diagnostics on the ABS system and nothing. That is why they even went to VW for assistance. Guess I will just have to press it with the service manager for an explanation as to why this is happening.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
109 Posts
Heading to the dealer tomorrow... anyone have anything to chime in on here?
By 46k mile. I was at the end of my 2nd set on my Town-n-Country. My 09 Jeep Liberty had this issue till the front caliper got so stuck it melted my front brake line by the time I got home. That was around 98k. My 19 Atlas w/8500 miles sofar is fine but I will keep an eye out. HOWEVER IMO, unless a vast majority of VWs are having this issue, it's NOT normal.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
8 Posts
I have had a similar situation occur. I had my 2018 Atlas SEL into the dealer for its 50,000 mi oil change and inspection. The dealer informed me that the front brakes had about 1-2mm left and the rear around 6mm and that the front should be replaced. I decided to wait and check prices. Less than 1000 mi/and a week later, I had metal on metal scraping, so I took it to a Firestone Auto Repair place close to my house. When they inspected the Atlas, the front passenger pads had 0/3mm remaining, front driver pads had 6mm, the rear both measured 7mm. The Firestone mechanics checked other parts of the system and said they couldn't find anything definitively wrong, so they didn't suggest throwing parts at it. Firestone replaced the pads and the damaged rotor. I contacted VW Customer Care and they wanted a third opinion/second dealer to look at it. The second dealer has now determined they could not find anything wrong and the new pads (~900 mi) seem to be wearing fine at this point. First, I'm wondering what may be wrong that caused this abnormal wear, but I'm also seeing others with potentially the same issue. Second, another dealer has lost my trust for not informing me of the obvious issues between the front sides. Gives me the feeling they knew the pads needed replacing, but wanted to sweep any other issues under the rug and hopefully I wouldn't realize them. I have saved the parts and all documentation moving forward.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
882 Posts
I have had a similar situation occur. I had my 2018 Atlas SEL into the dealer for its 50,000 mi oil change and inspection. The dealer informed me that the front brakes had about 1-2mm left and the rear around 6mm and that the front should be replaced. I decided to wait and check prices. Less than 1000 mi/and a week later, I had metal on metal scraping, so I took it to a Firestone Auto Repair place close to my house. When they inspected the Atlas, the front passenger pads had 0/3mm remaining, front driver pads had 6mm, the rear both measured 7mm. The Firestone mechanics checked other parts of the system and said they couldn't find anything definitively wrong, so they didn't suggest throwing parts at it. Firestone replaced the pads and the damaged rotor. I contacted VW Customer Care and they wanted a third opinion/second dealer to look at it. The second dealer has now determined they could not find anything wrong and the new pads (~900 mi) seem to be wearing fine at this point. First, I'm wondering what may be wrong that caused this abnormal wear, but I'm also seeing others with potentially the same issue. Second, another dealer has lost my trust for not informing me of the obvious issues between the front sides. Gives me the feeling they knew the pads needed replacing, but wanted to sweep any other issues under the rug and hopefully I wouldn't realize them. I have saved the parts and all documentation moving forward.
I wonder if the uneven wear has anything to do with the lane keeping system? I guess the other questions would be - do other vehicles/brands ever have uneven wear with the modern safety systems? We have no idea...maybe it's not all that uncommon. No clue. At 50K it's not odd to replace brake pads. Was the call to VW b/c you felt that the dealer didn't do a good job assessing your vehicle? The dealer told you to replace them and you refused. Dealer brake service is almost always competitive with Firestone etc. and at least with a dealer you know they used VW parts.
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
109 Posts
I wonder if the uneven wear has anything to do with the lane keeping system? I guess the other questions would be - do other vehicles/brands ever have uneven wear with the modern safety systems? We have no idea...maybe it's not all that uncommon. No clue. At 50K it's not odd to replace brake pads. Was the call to VW b/c you felt that the dealer didn't do a good job assessing your vehicle? The dealer told you to replace them and you refused. Dealer brake service is almost always competitive with Firestone etc. and at least with a dealer you know they used VW parts.
This is a good thought. The lane assist could cause uneven wear. (We actually turned ours off along with most Of the other tech features. Our atlas has 35k on it now and I’m starting to feel slight pulsating. I just got the 30k mike svc completed and all was well. Assuming I still have it when it’s time for brakes I’ll report back if I had uneven wear.

As for VW and the dealers. Everything is “normal” when they have no legit answers to your concerns.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
882 Posts
This is a good thought. The lane assist could cause uneven wear. (We actually turned ours off along with most Of the other tech features. Our atlas has 35k on it now and I’m starting to feel slight pulsating. I just got the 30k mike svc completed and all was well. Assuming I still have it when it’s time for brakes I’ll report back if I had uneven wear.

As for VW and the dealers. Everything is “normal” when they have no legit answers to your concerns.
To be fair, can you imagine working at a dealer and dealing with the day-in-day-out folks that come with a myriad of concerns that are often user error, noises that can't be re-produced, etc.? Just always trying to look at these issues from both sides so I at least understand why things are handled the way they are (whether I agree with them or not). They can only fix what is broken or what they can show is broken (so they get paid on the warranty claim) and often, people just get upset when the dealer says "normal" when it actually may be/within the tolerance of the system. Also understand the "flat rate" system that dealer techs are typically paid on....it unfortunately incentivizes not spending a lot of time on minor issues that will be hard to pinpoint....not the best for customers. They don't get paid to chase a phantom rattle in a back seat for 2 hours and not be able to re-produce it. Back on topic - no clue here on the brakes, seems like a non-issue - replace pads and move on. My front rotors need to be replaced at 22K - pulsing from slow downs at high speeds. I'll DIY it as the VWs are easy and the rotors aren't v. expensive. Not odd for a large/heavy vehicle driven primarily around town...our Honda Odyssey always had brake rotor issues (warping etc.).
 

·
Banned
Joined
·
109 Posts
To be fair, can you imagine working at a dealer and dealing with the day-in-day-out folks that come with a myriad of concerns that are often user error, noises that can't be re-produced, etc.? Just always trying to look at these issues from both sides so I at least understand why things are handled the way they are (whether I agree with them or not). They can only fix what is broken or what they can show is broken (so they get paid on the warranty claim) and often, people just get upset when the dealer says "normal" when it actually may be/within the tolerance of the system. Also understand the "flat rate" system that dealer techs are typically paid on....it unfortunately incentivizes not spending a lot of time on minor issues that will be hard to pinpoint....not the best for customers. They don't get paid to chase a phantom rattle in a back seat for 2 hours and not be able to re-produce it. Back on topic - no clue here on the brakes, seems like a non-issue - replace pads and move on. My front rotors need to be replaced at 22K - pulsing from slow downs at high speeds. I'll DIY it as the VWs are easy and the rotors aren't v. expensive. Not odd for a large/heavy vehicle driven primarily around town...our Honda Odyssey always had brake rotor issues (warping etc.).
Good point. I can’t imagine being a service advisors with today’s autos. Especially with forums available. Lol. Kinda like running to the doctor because every time you get sick you self diagnose on WebMD.

I just did my rotors and pads on my tundra and was surprised how easy it was. Especially being my first time ever self replacing. Been overpaying for this service for way to long.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1 Posts
Got my 2018 Atlas SEL Premium in March 2018. It has roughly 46,000 miles on it.

Short story: Why would the passenger side brake pads wear way faster (front passenger pad with 1/32 remaining, rear passenger pad 3/32 remaining) versus the driver side brake pads wearing appropriately with my mileage (front driver pad with 8/32 remaining, rear driver pad 6/32 remaining)

Long story: Took it in this week for a “grinding” noise that I was hearing from the front passenger brake pad and rotor. Originally I thought that something was stuck in between the pad and the rotor because back in September of 2018 there was an acorn of all things stuck in between the pad/rotor. The dealer called me within an hour or so and explained that they were surprised with the uneven wear from and that the pads should not have worn so much. They said they were going to do some test with the ABS system and check a few other things. They sent information to Volkswagen technical (whatever or whoever that is) and they said it was “normal” and to replace the pad/rotor. The dealer then asked for “assistance” from VW and they decline helping at all financially. Background... I had an unexplained vibration in the front passenger side that I had taken to another VW dealer two times. Each time they said they diagnosed the issue and just did an alignment each time to “fix” the problem.

So I called VW customer care and talked to a very nice lady that basically didn’t help at all. She apologized a bunch and basically told me she could not give me an explanation of WHY this is happening and to talk to the service manager. But I am not going to replace the pads/rotors without someone explaining WHY this is happening so that it doesn’t happen AGAIN!

HOW can this happen? Has anyone experienced this?
Who can I talk to at VW technical or something to get an answer?
the reason the brakes are wearing on one side is that’s how the lane keep assist bounces you back in the lane it will wear the breaks on one side only
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
882 Posts
the reason the brakes are wearing on one side is that’s how the lane keep assist bounces you back in the lane it will wear the breaks on one side only
The lane assist keeps you in your lane by using the steering system, not the braking system.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
882 Posts
Another easy place to check is to ensure that hte slider pins are lubed and moving feely on both calipers. On my Sportwagen, I have more wear on teh d. side. The XDS system which uses the ABS/brakes to reduce understeer in tight cornering situations also could be at play - it uses the brakes out the opposite side you are turning to help you turn-in BUT this is going to be aggressive driving, not just daily type stuff.
 
1 - 15 of 15 Posts
Top